{"claim": {"id": "c1", "type": "compare_groups", "stat": "usable_fraction", "group_a": {"pool": "mine", "condition": "any"}, "group_b": {"pool": "cold", "condition": "any"}, "direction": ">", "rationale": "The owner's own head (mine, 0.45) shows much higher usable fraction than cold-exposure sessions (cold, 0.11), likely because the owner can adjust the headband more carefully."}, "result": {"outcome": "malformed", "reason": "groups overlap on 2 sessions"}, "tier": "malformed"}
{"claim": {"id": "c2", "type": "correlation", "x": "gyro_rms_mean", "y": "usable_fraction", "pool": "all", "sign": "-", "rationale": "Higher head motion (gyro) should reduce the fraction of usable epochs due to motion artifacts corrupting the signal."}, "result": {"outcome": "not_supported", "rho": -0.07337271943211592, "p_stated": 0.2552744725527447, "p_opposite": 0.7449255074492551, "n": 78, "p_stated_holm": 1.0, "p_opposite_holm": 1.0}, "tier": "inconclusive at this n"}
{"claim": {"id": "c3", "type": "correlation", "x": "mean_logalpha", "y": "mean_logtheta", "pool": "all", "sign": "+", "rationale": "Alpha and theta bands typically co-vary as slow oscillations; positive correlation in log power is expected across sessions."}, "result": {"outcome": "supported", "rho": 0.8896649458447211, "p_stated": 9.999000099990002e-05, "p_opposite": 1.0, "n": 39, "p_stated_holm": 0.0006999300069993001, "p_opposite_holm": 1.0}, "tier": "empirical"}
{"claim": {"id": "c4", "type": "correlation", "x": "mean_logbeta", "y": "mean_loggamma", "pool": "all", "sign": "+", "rationale": "Beta and gamma bands often increase together during active states; a positive correlation in log power is plausible across sessions."}, "result": {"outcome": "supported", "rho": 0.9663933596517866, "p_stated": 9.999000099990002e-05, "p_opposite": 1.0, "n": 39, "p_stated_holm": 0.0006999300069993001, "p_opposite_holm": 1.0}, "tier": "empirical"}
{"claim": {"id": "c5", "type": "compare_groups", "stat": "mean_index", "group_a": {"pool": "mine", "condition": "any"}, "group_b": {"pool": "cold", "condition": "any"}, "direction": ">", "rationale": "The activation index (beta+gamma)/(theta+alpha) is higher in mine (0.078) than cold (0.062), suggesting the owner's baseline state is more aroused or the cold dampens high-frequency power."}, "result": {"outcome": "malformed", "reason": "groups overlap on 2 sessions"}, "tier": "malformed"}
{"claim": {"id": "c6", "type": "compare_groups", "stat": "mean_logalpha", "group_a": {"pool": "mine", "condition": "any"}, "group_b": {"pool": "cold", "condition": "any"}, "direction": "<", "rationale": "Mine has lower mean logalpha (0.48) than cold (0.82), possibly because cold exposure increases alpha power (relaxation response) while the owner's baseline is more active."}, "result": {"outcome": "malformed", "reason": "groups overlap on 2 sessions"}, "tier": "malformed"}
{"claim": {"id": "c7", "type": "correlation", "x": "minutes", "y": "usable_fraction", "pool": "all", "sign": "+", "rationale": "Longer recording sessions may allow better electrode settling, leading to higher usable fraction over time."}, "result": {"outcome": "not_supported", "rho": 0.11761002149879202, "p_stated": 0.10288971102889712, "p_opposite": 0.8972102789721028, "n": 115, "p_stated_holm": 0.5144485551444856, "p_opposite_holm": 1.0}, "tier": "inconclusive at this n"}
{"claim": {"id": "c8", "type": "compare_groups", "stat": "mean_logalpha", "group_a": {"pool": "mine_sleep", "condition": "any"}, "group_b": {"pool": "all", "condition": "any"}, "direction": "<", "rationale": "Sleep shows very low alpha (0.17) compared to all sessions (0.73), consistent with alpha suppression during sleep."}, "result": {"outcome": "malformed", "reason": "groups overlap on 1 sessions"}, "tier": "malformed"}
{"claim": {"id": "c9", "type": "correlation", "x": "gyro_rms_mean", "y": "mean_index", "pool": "all", "sign": "-", "rationale": "Higher head motion should disrupt the activation index by introducing noise that inflates theta/alpha or disrupts beta/gamma balance."}, "result": {"outcome": "not_supported", "rho": -0.10689655172413792, "p_stated": 0.2953704629537046, "p_opposite": 0.7058294170582942, "n": 29, "p_stated_holm": 1.0, "p_opposite_holm": 1.0}, "tier": "inconclusive at this n"}
{"claim": {"id": "c10", "type": "compare_groups", "stat": "usable_fraction", "group_a": {"pool": "mine", "condition": "any"}, "group_b": {"pool": "mine_sleep", "condition": "any"}, "direction": "<", "rationale": "Mine (0.45) has lower usable fraction than mine_sleep (0.96), which is expected since sleep epochs are cleaner and the overnight recording was well-worn."}, "result": {"outcome": "abstain", "reason": "underpowered: n_a=14, n_b=1 (need 5 each)"}, "tier": "abstain"}
{"claim": {"id": "c11", "type": "correlation", "x": "mean_logbeta", "y": "mean_logalpha", "pool": "all", "sign": "-", "rationale": "Beta and alpha are often inversely related (beta up during alertness, alpha up during rest), so a negative correlation is plausible across sessions."}, "result": {"outcome": "refuted", "rho": 0.7550359348112157, "p_stated": 1.0, "p_opposite": 9.999000099990002e-05, "n": 39, "p_stated_holm": 1.0, "p_opposite_holm": 0.0006999300069993001}, "tier": "refuted"}
{"claim": {"id": "c12", "type": "correlation", "x": "mean_loggamma", "y": "mean_logalpha", "pool": "all", "sign": "-", "rationale": "Gamma power is typically low during relaxed states where alpha dominates, suggesting a negative correlation between gamma and alpha across sessions."}, "result": {"outcome": "refuted", "rho": 0.6489523231096264, "p_stated": 1.0, "p_opposite": 9.999000099990002e-05, "n": 39, "p_stated_holm": 1.0, "p_opposite_holm": 0.0006999300069993001}, "tier": "refuted"}
